spot_img
Friday, August 8, 2025
spot_img

Rideau Lakes council fails to override mayor’s veto on Chantry office costing; staff now tasked with repair plan

spot_img
LAURIE WEIR

Rideau Lakes council failed to override Mayor Arie Hoogenboom’s veto on the Chantry office retrofit project during a special meeting on Wednesday, May 28. 

This caused an eruption of applause from members of the gallery in attendance.

The veto, issued under Ontario’s strong mayor powers, blocked a resolution that would have allowed staff to obtain formal pricing to retrofit the existing municipal office in Chantry. The motion failed to meet the two-thirds majority required.

Those in favour of blocking the veto were Coun. Paula Banks, Coun. Jeff Banks, Coun. Sue Dunfield, Coun. Linda Carr and Deputy Mayor Deborah Anne Hutchings. Opposed were Coun. Ron Pollard, Coun. Marcia Maxwell and Mayor Hoogenboom.

More than $138,000 has already been spent on design work and preliminary planning for the retrofit. That work is now on hold.

Tensions ran high during the meeting, with several councillors accusing the mayor of obstructing transparency by preventing a basic cost comparison between retrofitting the existing office and building new.

Maxwell expressed concern about the tone of the debate, saying she felt intimidated by the process and by pressure from colleagues and members of the public. “The intimidation around this table is appalling,” she said. “It’s wrong on every level.”

She and Pollard could have blocked the veto, but they held firm in stance against moving the project forward. Pollard said it was too much too soon with all the other project they have on the go, even though he’d like to see a cost comparison. “It’s just too much right now for taxpayers,” he said. 

Hoogenboom defended his decision to veto the renovation project, stating the retrofit does not align with provincial housing and infrastructure priorities.

“This is the largest single capital expenditure we’ve made in 25 years,” he said. “There has been no formal public consultation, financing is not yet secured, and the township risks taking on long-term debt at a time when interest rates and construction costs remain uncertain.”

He also reiterated support for an alternative proposal involving five acres of “donated” land, which he says could support housing development tied to a new subdivision. “This option was not properly considered by council,” he said.

But J. Banks raised red flags over the land offer, calling it “bonkers” and potentially unethical.

“We are not allowed to accept land from a developer in exchange for favourable treatment,” he said. “That puts us in a bad spot. It’s a conflict.”

J. Banks also questioned the closed-session discussions held around the land offer, saying council and the public were not given enough information to assess the implications. “I’m concerned about what might have been promised outside of this chamber,” he said.

Following the failed override, council voted to suspend its procedural bylaw to allow a new motion from P. Banks to proceed. That motion, which passed, calls for a legal opinion on whether the mayor’s use of the veto constitutes a misuse of power under the Municipal Act. It also directs staff and consultants to provide written clarification explaining why the Chantry project was described as flawed.

A formal letter of concern will also be sent to the Minister of Municipal Affairs and Housing, MPP Steve Clark, the Association of Municipalities of Ontario, and all Ontario municipalities.

With the veto standing, P. Banks asked that staff prepare a plan to address urgent building issues, including a leaking roof, backed-up plumbing and the building’s lack of accessibility compliance. Constructed in 1979, the Chantry office requires upgrades to meet current standards under the Accessibility for Ontarians with Disabilities Act.

The next meeting of council will be held at 6 p.m. on June 3.

spot_img
spot_img

Hot this week

Smiths Falls Police address crash, bar incident and youth assault in series of responses

SUBMITTED No injuries after collision with hydro pole. Driver facing...

King Charles III Coronation Medal recognizes exceptional Canadians

LAURIE WEIR In a special ceremony hosted by Lanark—Frontenac—Kingston MP...

UCDSB to host holocaust survivor Andy Rèti as Tour for Humanity returns

SUBMITTED The Tour for Humanity mobile classroom will return to...

Smiths Falls History & Mystery: Farmer grocer solider reeve

Ambrose Halladay moved into the Keyhole House in Smiths...

Impaired charge laid after a collision on Roger Stevens Drive

SUBMITTED A Toronto resident has been charged following a single...
spot_img

Stolen boat motor recovered in Arden

SUBMITTED BY OPP EAST REGION Arrest Warrant To Be Issued...

Council divided over veto, integrity complaints, and strong mayor powers in Rideau Lakes

LAURIE WEIR CHANTRY — The controversy around the Chantry office...

Disturbance results in multiple charges

SUBMITTED BY LANARK COUNTY OPP CARLETON PLACE - The Lanark...

Butterflies take flight again in Perth for second annual memorial release

Community gathers Aug. 20 to honour loved ones through...

Canada Post clarifies that the red flag’s only use is for outgoing mail

LAURIE WEIR PORTLAND — Rural residents, did you know that...

Six charged in Smiths Falls police investigations including impaired driving and animal cruelty

SUBMITTED / SMITHS FALLS POLICE SERVICE Breach investigation results in...

HOMETOWN HAPPENINGS: Markets, music and family fun this weekend

Looking for something to do this weekend? We’ve got...

Related Articles

Popular Categories

spot_img