Mud and manure made for lively debate at Rideau Lakes council Monday, June 22, where councillors wrestled with a question familiar to many rural communities: when does a seasonal farming reality become a municipal problem?
A request for Rideau Lakes to create a bylaw regulating mud, manure and other agricultural debris on municipal roads prompted a lengthy council debate June 22 before councillors ultimately agreed to stick with the township’s existing approach.
The discussion began with correspondence from resident Steve Kazimer, who asked the township to consider a bylaw after raising concerns about mud and manure left on Hunters Road during seasonal farming operations.
Staff recommended against creating new regulations, noting the issue had also come before council in 2009 and 2017, with previous councils choosing education, monitoring and cooperation over enforcement.
Deputy Mayor Jeff Banks said he understood the concerns raised by residents living along Hunters Road, describing the accumulation of mud and manure as both a nuisance and a safety issue.
“I don’t understand how we’re going to rectify this situation without a bylaw,” Banks said. “I’m 100 per cent for farming, but there has to be some respect for the residents also.”
Banks suggested staff continue discussions with the farmer and explore options to ensure roads are cleaned when necessary.
Coun. Paula Banks also supported further review, saying the township should examine whether there are practical solutions without affecting normal farming operations.
“I grew up on a farm, so I don’t want to jeopardize any farming operation,” she said. “But we can’t say this is a widespread problem and we’ve only got one complaint and there’s nothing we can do about it.”
She later proposed deferring the matter to staff for additional review, but the motion failed.
Other councillors argued the existing approach was appropriate.
Coun. Debbie Hutchings, a farmer herself, said there needs to be balance between agriculture and neighbouring residents. She noted that farming activities are seasonal and farmers need access to municipal roads to move equipment between fields.
“I am for the farmer to be able to use the road,” Hutchings said. “It is seasonal.”
Coun. Marcia Maxwell said muddy roads are a reality in a rural municipality and cautioned against regulating farmers over an issue that occurs throughout the township.
Coun. Dustin Bulloch agreed, noting staff had received only one formal complaint despite similar conditions occurring elsewhere.
“I have a hard time writing a policy for one area of complaint,” Bulloch said.
Deputy Fire Chief and Community Safety Officer Shane Peters said staff already respond to complaints by working with the roads department and property owners when issues arise. He cautioned that enforcing a bylaw would be difficult because agricultural equipment is not licensed in the same way as motor vehicles, making enforcement challenging.
He also questioned how a bylaw would define debris.
“Where do we draw the line?” Peters asked, noting grass clippings, snow and other materials end up on roads.
Roads Manager Dan Chant told council crews already sweep Hunters Road when complaints are received, in addition to regular road maintenance. He said that while mud from farm equipment can be found on roads across the township during busy agricultural seasons, Hunters Road is the only location that has generated formal complaints.
Council defeated both a motion to defer the matter and a proposed amendment that would have committed the township to additional sweeping of Hunters Road before approving staff’s original recommendation.
The approved motion thanks Kazimer for bringing the matter forward and directs staff to continue monitoring and responding to concerns about mud, manure and other debris on municipal roads through existing operational practices.
Keep connected to your community—Read the latest Rideau Lakes news.
