Smiths Falls councillors are divided over whether historically significant buildings should receive heritage designation when property owners object, as the town moves toward a provincial deadline that could see several properties lose existing protections.
At the Oct. 19 committee of the whole meeting, councillors supported proceeding with six uncontested designations while seeking further information on three properties whose owners have raised concerns.
[bsa_pro_ad_space id=11][bsa_pro_ad_space id=8]Manager of development services Karl Grenke explained that changes to the Ontario Heritage Act mean certain listed properties will lose their heritage protection at the beginning of 2027 unless the municipality takes steps to designate them.
The Municipal Heritage Committee spent the past several years reviewing properties and identifying nine considered worthy of protection.
[bsa_pro_ad_space id=10]Notices of intent to designate were issued earlier this year, with the objection period ending Oct. 2.
No objections were received for 65, 89 and 97 Chambers St., 84 and 102 Brockville St., and the municipally owned Stone Arch Bridge.
[bsa_pro_ad_space id=12]However, objections were filed concerning 30 Chambers St., 78 Brockville St., known as Rockothlin House, and 21 Market St. N., known as the Armoury.
[bsa_pro_ad_space id=11]Coun. Chris McGuire praised the work of municipal staff and the heritage committee, describing the progress made during the council term as unprecedented in his experience.
[bsa_pro_ad_space id=8]“The amount of work that’s gotten done in this time with the municipal heritage committee, with Karl and Marie Elmsley, has really been like nothing I’ve seen since 2015, when I’ve been on the committee,” McGuire said.
He explained that the committee had narrowed its focus to significant properties outside the downtown Heritage Conservation District, particularly commercial buildings considered more vulnerable to inappropriate renovations or redevelopment.
McGuire also emphasized that heritage designation could make property owners eligible for financial assistance through the town’s Community Improvement Plan.
“It’s not just a stick, there’s also a carrot,” he said, referring to grants and tax incentives available for heritage-related improvements.
Coun. Jay Brennan took a different position.
“I’m not a fan of designating properties that the owners oppose designation. Full stop,” Brennan said.
He cited examples from other municipalities where owners had raised concerns about increased insurance premiums following heritage designation.
“My preference would be to drop these three designations, proceed with the other ones,” he said.
Coun. Dawn Quinn agreed that preserving historic buildings was important but questioned whether the municipality should impose restrictions against an owner’s wishes.
“I totally believe that we do need to protect our heritage buildings, but I believe we need to be doing it with the consent of the property owners,” Quinn said.
“They are the people that have bought, they are the people that have paid.”
Quinn said the municipality should work with owners and provide guidance rather than impose designations they do not want.
“They feel like they’re being dictated to,” she said.
Mayor Shawn Pankow supported continuing the designation process, acknowledging concerns about insurance costs while emphasizing the importance of protecting the town’s architectural heritage.
“There’s still valid value in pursuing this a little bit further,” Pankow said.
He suggested a future council could consider property tax relief for designated heritage buildings to help offset additional costs.
Coun. Peter McKenna also supported further investigation before making final decisions on the contested properties.
For 30 Chambers St., Grenke said the owner may be willing to accept a narrower designation that removes certain references to window and door materials and features at the rear of the building.
At Rockothlin House, the objection questions the historical accuracy and significance of some architectural features identified for protection.
The Armoury’s owner expressed concerns about restrictions on future changes to the commercial building.
Grenke said cultural heritage evaluation reports, estimated at approximately $5,000 each, could provide stronger evidence to support designation decisions and help defend them if appealed to the Ontario Land Tribunal.
He cautioned that withdrawing the notices could result in the properties losing existing heritage protections and delay any future designation efforts.
McKenna favoured obtaining the additional information before making decisions.
“I would appreciate that information before I designated those three,” he said.
Committee members ultimately supported proceeding with the uncontested properties while directing staff to continue discussions and obtain further heritage assessments where appropriate.
The three contested properties are expected to return for consideration before the statutory deadline, potentially during the next council term.
The designation of 102 Brockville St. was considered separately after McGuire declared a conflict of interest and left the room. No objection had been received for that property, and committee members supported proceeding with its designation.
Grenke emphasized that heritage designation does not require owners to restore their buildings or dictate how properties may be used. Instead, it protects specifically identified heritage attributes and requires municipal approval for certain alterations.
Keep connected to your community—read the latest Smiths Falls news.


