Three candidates seeking the mayor’s chair offered different approaches to spending, recreation, policing, water, health care and other municipal issues during an all-candidates meeting hosted by the Rotary Club of Smiths Falls.
Peter McKenna, Nate Morris and Christopher Cummings faced a series of prepared questions before the meeting turned to written questions submitted by members of the audience.
[bsa_pro_ad_space id=11][bsa_pro_ad_space id=8]The candidates also used the evening to define what they would bring to the mayor’s office.
Morris, a first-time candidate, positioned himself as the choice for significant change and repeatedly returned to affordability, lower water bills and municipal spending.
[bsa_pro_ad_space id=10]Cummings pointed to his previous 12 years on council and business and governance experience, while arguing experience and change do not have to be competing choices.
McKenna emphasized stability and his experience as one of the town’s current councillors.
[bsa_pro_ad_space id=12]“I’m not running against anything. I’m running for Smiths Falls,” McKenna said. “We need steady, calm leadership to guide us over the next four years.”
[bsa_pro_ad_space id=11]Regional recreation complex
Asked about a proposed $50-million recreation complex, McKenna first corrected the description of the project as an arena, saying the concept is for a broader regional recreation facility that could include pickleball, indoor soccer and basketball.
[bsa_pro_ad_space id=8]He said Smiths Falls could not undertake a project of that size alone and it would require municipal partners and support from senior levels of government.
“The Town of Smiths Falls cannot develop a complex like this on their own and we wouldn’t be that foolish,” he said.
Morris was more skeptical.
“I feel like I’m going to be a wet blanket again,” he said, questioning the likelihood of securing enough financial support from neighbouring municipalities to make the project viable.
Cummings said the concept has merit, but its price tag cannot be ignored.
“$50 million, guess what? We don’t have it,” he said.
He described the facility as aspirational and said it could benefit physical and mental health, serve residents of different ages and act as an economic driver, but firm financial commitments would be needed before moving ahead.
ALTO
The proposed high-speed rail project also exposed differences among the candidates.
Morris was unequivocal.
“I’m absolutely not in favour of ALTO,” he said.
Cummings raised concerns about land acquisition, relationships with neighbouring municipalities and possible effects on existing passenger rail service, but said he was not prepared to dismiss potential economic benefits, including the possibility of a maintenance facility.
McKenna said the project is a federal responsibility and the municipality’s role is largely one of advocacy. He said council has not opposed ALTO at this stage because there could be benefits if Smiths Falls secured a station or maintenance facility.
Policing
Asked about concerns surrounding the cost of policing, all three candidates discussed the future of the Smiths Falls Police Service.
Morris said he sees value in retaining a local police service but wants reforms, including greater transparency, body-worn cameras and better cost control. He said he supports keeping the local service but remains open to considering the OPP.
Cummings strongly supported retaining the Smiths Falls Police Service. Drawing on his previous experience on the police services board, he said representatives from communities policed by the OPP had warned him against giving up a municipal service.
McKenna also supported retaining the local force and said changing police services during the next term would risk dividing the community.
Water sparks sharp exchange
One of the evening’s sharper exchanges came after the meeting moved to written questions from the audience.
“Water quality has been identified as an issue during the election. Have you visited our water treatment plant and understand how it operates?” the candidates were asked.
Cummings said he has visited the plant and has confidence in its operators.
“I believe our water is safe. I’m drinking Smiths Falls water right now,” he said.
McKenna took direct aim at allegations surrounding the town’s water.
“There has been terrible fear-mongering around the quality of our water,” he said, adding that suggestions of a conspiracy to conceal water-testing results were “disgusting.”
Morris pushed back on that characterization, saying he was not alleging a “massive conspiracy” and maintained the concerns he has raised are supported by evidence he has made public.
He said neither McKenna nor Cummings had “substantively addressed” the issues he has raised and objected to having his concerns characterized as fear-mongering.
Recruiting doctors
Another written question challenged the candidates to go beyond advocating for more physicians, asking what municipal “levers” they would use to make recruitment a reality.
McKenna said health care is primarily a provincial responsibility but municipalities still have influence and resources. He pointed to his experience in physician recruitment and said Smiths Falls currently contributes about $10,000 annually toward recruitment in partnership with the hospital.
He said he would be open to asking council to invest more, but does not favour large financial payouts to entice doctors.
Morris took the opposite position on incentives.
“I’m going to take a different position than Peter … we do need to bribe doctors,” Morris said, quickly acknowledging “bribing is kind of a strong word.”
He argued Smiths Falls is competing against municipalities with stronger incentive programs and said failing to compete leaves residents without doctors and creates costs elsewhere. He said he would support spending more on a competitive recruitment program and personally meet prospective physicians to determine what might persuade them to practise in Smiths Falls.
Cummings recalled helping establish a physician recruitment task force during his previous time on council and pointed to his current health-care governance experience.
Then he drew laughs by turning to McKenna.
“This might not be the smartest thing for me to say tonight, but when I’m elected as mayor, I’m going to call Peter,” Cummings said, acknowledging McKenna’s health-care recruitment experience. “Peter, if I’m elected, you’re my first call.”
Heritage and downtown
Candidates were also asked if they would enforce the guidelines and standards of the town’s recently established Heritage Conservation District.
Morris said he is committed to preserving the town’s heritage and believes too many historic structures have already been lost. But he challenged the premise in the question that Smiths Falls has a vibrant downtown, pointing to vacant storefronts.
He said the approaching 200th anniversary of the Rideau Canal presents an opportunity to use the community’s history to help reinvigorate the local economy.
Cummings recalled helping establish the municipal heritage committee during his previous time on council. He said he initially had some apprehension about creating the downtown Heritage Conservation District but believes it was a good move.
At the same time, he said the process cannot create unnecessary barriers for property owners.
“People won’t buy buildings in Smiths Falls if we put up a bunch of roadblocks for them to improve their property,” Cummings said.
McKenna said the Heritage Conservation District was identified as part of council’s four-year strategic plan and followed about three years of consultation before coming into effect this summer. He acknowledged there have already been challenges in working with a property owner seeking to improve a building, but said he supports the district and the opportunities it provides.
He also pointed to the town’s Community Improvement Plan, which allows property and business owners to apply for financial assistance for improvements, including work to building facades. McKenna said the incentives are intended to help offset the cost to owners who are being asked to meet heritage standards.
“If we’re going to ask businesses in the district to do this kind of work, the town has incentivized that by adding the Community Improvement Plan that’s available to help them,” he said.
McKenna said the town will learn as the relatively new district evolves, but its long-term objective should be protecting the character of the downtown.
“We do not want to see beautiful brick facades or heritage aspects being torn apart and vinyl covered up,” he said.
Work experience and the mayor’s role
Asked about their current occupations and professional backgrounds, Morris and Cummings also addressed how they would approach the time commitment required of the mayor.
Morris said he operates a mycology laboratory and an agroforestry operation on a farm in Westport and works with hemp cultivars. He said some of that work would continue, but the mayor’s position would come first.
“If I’m elected mayor, I will pursue that as a full-time job,” Morris said. “I think the only way you could be an effective mayor is to do it on a full-time basis.”
Cummings outlined a career that included banking and financial services and said he is now retired. He said his current term as chair of the Catholic District School Board of Eastern Ontario would end when the new mayor takes office, and other commitments would also end.
“Yes, full-time mayor,” Cummings said.
McKenna pointed to his experience as executive director of a community health organization, 10 years at Brockville General Hospital, service in the Royal Canadian Navy and work at Hershey and the Rideau Regional Centre.
He also drew laughs when he added another job to the list.
“I was the best bartender in the Lee Hotel that you’ve ever seen,” McKenna said.
Accessibility
Another audience question stated Smiths Falls has the second-highest per-capita number of people with disabilities and asked what the candidates would do to lead the community toward becoming barrier-free.
Cummings said the town needs to identify existing barriers and work with agencies that can help develop solutions. He said he would assess what is working and what is not and called accessibility one of his priorities.
McKenna pointed to work already undertaken through the town’s accessibility committee, including curb cuts, accessible pedestrian crossings and improvements to streets, sidewalks and parks.
Morris focused on transportation and mobility.
He proposed exploring a weekly shuttle that could help seniors and residents with serious mobility challenges reach grocery stores, thrift stores and downtown businesses.
He also said some sidewalks, roads and public spaces remain difficult to navigate, singling out parking lots and pathways at Lower Reach Park as areas needing better maintenance.
Montague boundary agreement
The final written question focused on the town’s longstanding boundary agreement with neighbouring Montague Township.
The question stated Smiths Falls pays Montague 50 per cent of property taxes from the affected area while Smiths Falls bears the cost of providing services, and asked: “What is your plan to extract us from this agreement?”
McKenna called the original arrangement a “bad deal,” particularly because the tax-sharing provision continues indefinitely.
He stressed, however, that Smiths Falls has a strong relationship with Montague and said discussions are continuing about finding a fair arrangement as development moves forward.
Morris agreed the agreement is problematic but said existing commitments must be honoured while the municipalities negotiate a fairer arrangement.
Cummings noted that when the original matter came before council, he was working as a financial adviser for Montague and declared a conflict of interest. He said he believes there is room for the municipalities to negotiate a new arrangement.
Different pitches for mayor
The differences among the three candidates were perhaps clearest in their closing pitches.
Morris argued Smiths Falls needs a change in political culture and said elected officials need to be more receptive to criticism.
“We need to accept constructive criticism. We need to look at evidence when it’s presented,” he said.
McKenna returned to his argument for experienced and steady leadership.
“I am not running against anything. I’m running for something,” he said, promising to “hold the gains” made during the past eight years while moving ahead at a pace the municipality can afford.
Cummings closed by rejecting the idea that voters must choose between the status quo and wholesale change.
“I’m not asking you to elect me because I believe everything in Smiths Falls needs to change. And I’m certainly not asking you to elect me because I believe everything should stay the same,” he said.
“This election isn’t about choosing between experience and change. We can have both.”
The all-candidates meeting was hosted by the Rotary Club of Smiths Falls at Royal Canadian Legion Branch 95 and moderated by Rotarian Doug Robbins. Audience members were invited to submit questions in writing during the event, with organizers reviewing the submissions before they were put to the candidates. It was standing room only in the Lancaster Room with several people standing in the back.
Cogeco’s YourTV Brockville-Smiths Falls recorded the meeting as part of its municipal election coverage. The full meeting is available on the YourTV Brockville-Smiths Falls YouTube channel.
Keep connected to your community—read the latest Smiths Falls news.
Follow our 2026 municipal election coverage in the Hometown News Election Centre.




